20.00 mL of a 0.077 M solution of silver nitrate, AgNO3, is mixed with 30.00 mL of a 0.043 M solution of sodium acetate, NaC2H3O2. Does a precipitate form? The Ksp of AgC2H3O2 is 2.5*10^-3.

Answers

Answer 1

Answer:

No, no precipitate is formed.

Explanation:

Hello there!

In this case, since the reaction between silver nitrate and sodium acetate is:

[tex]AgNO_3(aq)+NaC_2H_3O_2(aq)\rightarrow AgC_2H_3O_2(s)+NaNO_3(aq)[/tex]

In such a way, we can calculate the concentration of silver and acetate ions in the solution as shown below, and considering that the final total volume is 50.00 mL or 0.0500 L:

[tex][Ag^+]=\frac{20.00mL*0.077M}{50.00mL}=0.0308M[/tex]

[tex][C_2H_3O_2^-]=\frac{30.00mL*0.043M}{50.00mL}=0.0258M[/tex]

In such a way, we can calculate the precipitation quotient by:

[tex]Q=[Ag^+][C_2H_3O_2^-]=0.0308*0.0258=7.95x10^{-4}[/tex]

Which is smaller than Ksp and meaning that the precipitation does not occur.

Regards!


Related Questions

un MODELO ATÓMICO es:
a. Una esfera con partículas positivas y negativas
b. La estructura mínima de la materia.
c. Una serie de descubrimientos.
d. La representación de un átomo donde se explica su comportamiento y características.

Answers

Answer:

Creo que es D pero no tan segura

Explanation:

Consider the following data on some weak acids and weak bases
acid
Ka
name formula
acetic acid
HCH3CO2
1.8 x10−5
hydrocyanic acid
HCN
4.9 x 10−10
base
Kb
name formula
pyridine
C5H5N
1.7 x 10−9
ammonia
NH3
1.8 x 10−5
Use this data to rank the following solutions in order of increasing pH. In other words, select a '1' next to the solution that will have the lowest pH, a '2' next to the solution that will have the next lowest pH, and so on.
a. 0.1M NaCH3CO2
b. 0.1M NH4Br
c. 0.1M NaBr
d. 0.1M KCN

Answers

Answer:

b < c < a < d

Explanation:

The weak acid with the lowest pKa will be the most acidic. In the other way, the conjugate base which the acid is weak will be strong.

The weak base with the lowest pKb will be the most basic. And the conjugate base of the weak base will be a strong acid.

Ka Acetic acid = 1.8x10-5

Ka HCN = 1.9x10-10

Kb pyridine = 1.7x10-9

Kb NH3 = 1.8x10-5

NH4Br is the conjugate base of a weak base. That means is a strong acid.

NH4Br has the lowest pH

NaBr is the conjugate base of a strong acid, HBr. That means NaBr is neutral

The most basic between the conjugate base of the acetic acid, NaCH3CO2 and KCN is KCN because the acetic acid is the stronger acid regard to HCN.

The rank is:

NH4Br < NaBr < NaCH3CO2 < KCN

b < c < a < d

Are sperm and egg cells exact copies of the plant cell

Answers

Answer:

No

Explanation:

thats scientifically impossible

You are performing an acid-base neutralization reaction in the laboratory to determine the concentration of an unknown base. You are supposed to titrate it with a monoprotic acid, but your lab partner accidentally fills your buret with sulfuric acid, a diprotic acid, with the same concentration as the acid called for in the experiment. How will the volume of diprotic acid compare to the volume of monoprotic acid you would have used

Answers

Answer:

Volume is reduced to half

Explanation:

Acid base titration are commonly used reactions in a lab, and are ofter used to get pH or different kind of solutions.

The neutralization of an acid base reaction is reached, when the solution (having added an indicator previously) changes its original color. chemically speaking, this occurs when the number of moles of the acid and the base are balanced and equal. In other words the following:

n₁ = n₂   (1)

This expression can also be expressed in function of concentration and volume:

M₁V₁ = M₂V₂   (2)

From here, solving for V₁:

V₁ = M₂V₂  / M₁

Now, this expression is true only when we have the same kind of substance that can lose or gain the same number of hydrogens.

Lets suppose that we have as base NaOH (Monoprotic base) and HCl (monoprotic acid), the titration reaction would be:

NaOH + HCl --------> NaCl + H₂O

As both of the species are monoprotic, the number of moles are the same  when they reach the equilibrium, so, expression  (2) can be used, and calculate volume or concentrations.

However, in this case, a partner made a mistake and use a diprotic acid, in this case, H₂SO₄, In this case, things chance because H₂SO₄ is diprotic, meaning that we need to dissociate two hydrogens in equilibrium, therefore, expression (2) would be something like this.

Acid: 1; Base: 2

H₂SO₄ + 2NaOH ------> Na₂SO₄ + H₂O

nH₂SO₄ = n₁ = 1

nNaOH = n₂ = 2

n₁/n₂ = 1/2

2n₁ = n₂   (3)

Writting this, in function of concentration and volume, it would be:

2M₁V₁ = M₂V₂   (4)

From here, if we solve for the volume of the acid (V₁):

V₁ = M₂V₂ / 2M₁

Therefore, according to this expression, we can see that the volume required of the acid would be half the volume required of the monoprotic acid. For example, if we need 50 mL of Chloridic acid to reach the equivalence point with NaOH, then, with H₂SO₄ it will only need 25 mL. This, of course, assuming that concentrations are the same, and volume of the base used, the same.

Hope this helps

What unit should you think of when using coefficients?

Answers

Answer:

Far as I know coefficients are unitless. sorry if this don't help ;)

WILL GIVE BRAINLIEST!!!

Answers

Answer:

The answer is B

Explanation:

The answer is B because representative particles can only be atoms.

Write the balanced equation for the equilibrium reaction for the dissociation ofsilver chloride in water, and write the K expression for this reaction. Then create an ICE chart. Since we know the equilibrium concentration of the silver ion, we can solve for Ksp.Does it agree with the literature value

Answers

Answer:

See explanation

Explanation:

Hello there!

In this case, since the the concentrations are not given, and not even the Ksp, we can solve this problem by setting up the chemical equation, the equilibrium constant expression and the ICE table only:

[tex]AgCl(s)\rightleftharpoons Ag^+(aq)+Cl^-(aq)[/tex]

Next, the equilibrium expression according to the produced aqueous species as the solid silver chloride is not involved in there:

[tex]Ksp=[Ag^+][Cl^-][/tex]

And therefore, the ICE table, in which x stands for the molar solubility of the silver chloride:

       [tex]\ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ AgCl(s)\rightleftharpoons Ag^+(aq)+Cl^-(aq)[/tex]

I          -                   0             0

C        -                   +x           +x

E        -                    x             x

Which leads to the following modified equilibrium expression:

[tex]Ksp=x^2[/tex]

Unfortunately, values were not given, and they cannot be arbitrarily assigned or assumed.

Regards!

A mixture of He, Ar, and Xe has a total pressure of 2.40 atm. The partial pressure of He is 0.300 atm, and the partial pressure of Ar is 0.250 atm. What is the partial pressure of Xe?
Express your answer to three significant figures and include the appropriate units.

Answers

1.85 atm

The total pressure is equal to the sum of all of the partial pressures, so 2.40 = 0.300 + 0.250 + pressure of Xe. Solving for the pressure of Xe, you get 1.85 atm.

The partial pressure of Xe in the mixture is 1.850 atm. (partial pressure of Xe = Total pressure - Partial pressure of He - Partial pressure of Ar = 1.850 atm).

To find the partial pressure of Xe, we need to subtract the partial pressures of He and Ar from the total pressure.

Total pressure = partial pressure of He + partial pressure of Ar + partial pressure of Xe

Given:

Total pressure = 2.40 atm

Partial pressure of He = 0.300 atm

Partial pressure of Ar = 0.250 atm

Let's solve for the partial pressure of Xe:

Partial pressure of Xe = Total pressure - Partial pressure of He - Partial pressure of Ar

Partial pressure of Xe = 2.40 atm - 0.300 atm - 0.250 atm

Partial pressure of Xe = 1.850 atm

Therefore, the partial pressure of Xe in the mixture is 1.850 atm.

To learn more about partial pressure of Xe  here

https://brainly.com/question/34136076

#SPJ2

Potassium nitrate, KNO3 , has a molar mass of 101.1 g/mol. In a constant-pressure calorimeter, 13.3 g of KNO3 is dissolved in 213 g of water at 23.00 °C . KNO3(s)−→−−H2OK+(aq)+NO−3(aq) The temperature of the resulting solution decreases to 19.60 °X . Assume that the resulting solution has the same specific heat as water, 4.184 J/(g·°C) , and that there is negligible heat loss to the surroundings. How much heat was released by the solution

Answers

Answer:

[tex]Q_{sln}=-3219.25 J[/tex]

Explanation:

Hello there!

In this case, for this calorimetry problem, it is possible for us to infer that the heat of the reaction of dissolution of KNO3 is absorbed by the solution composed by the former and water so that we can write:

[tex]Q_{rxn}=-Q_{sln}[/tex]

Thus, given the mass, specific heat and temperature of the solution, we plug in the data to obtain the heat absorbed, by the reaction:

[tex]Q_{rxn}=-m_{sln}C_{sln}\Delta T _{sln}\\\\Q_{rxn}=-(13.3+213)g(4.184\frac{J}{yg\°C} )(19.60-23.00)\°C\\\\Q_{rxn}=3219.25J[/tex]

Also, we can say the the heat released by the solution was -3219.25 J.

Best regards!

Select the TRUE statements below regarding the coordination compound prepared in lab. Group of answer choices The coordination compound contained a complex ion that was covalently bonded to sulfate. The ligand must have at least one unshared pair of valence electrons in order to covalently bond with transition metal in the coordination compound. Ethanol was used during crystallization of the coordination compound because the compound is soluble in ethanol. The ammonia is covalently bonded to the transition metal. The colors of many coordination compounds are the result of light absorption by the d electrons on the transition metal.

Answers

Answer: Hello the compound is missing but I was able to get the Full question and missing compound . ( compound = copper sulfate )

answer : statement ; 2 , 3 and 5

Explanation:

The true statements regarding the coordination compound ( copper sulfate ) are :

The ligand must have at least one unshared pair of valence electrons in order to covalently bond with transition metal in the coordination compound ( statement 2 )Ethanol was used during crystallization of the coordination compound because the compound is soluble in ethanol ( statement 3 ) The colors of many coordination compounds are the result of light absorption by the d electrons on the transition metal ( statement 5 )

During the coordination of compounds dative bonds exits between the transition metals and the Ligands molecules

2 Which of the gases in air are elements? Explain how you can tell.​

Answers

Answer:

I'll explain.

Explanation:

The molecules of two different elements, nitrogen and oxygen, make up about 99 percent of the air. The rest includes small amounts of argon and carbon dioxide. Oxygen is the life-giving element in the air. You can tell because they're on the periodic table which is a table for elements.

Explanation:

nitrogen and oxygen are the gases in the air which are elements you can simply say it by looking the periodic table

Determine the number of electrons in an Cl ion with a charge of -3

Answers

Answer:

There are 20 electrons.

Explanation:

Chlorine has 17 electrons in its atom to begin with (you can tell from the proton number in the periodic table).

A charge of -3 means that the chlorine atom gained 3 electrons, and now needs to lose 3 electrons to return to its atom configuration.

what is the difference between transmutation and natural radioactivity​

Answers

radioactivity refers to the natural transmutation, whereas transmutation refers to the change of one chemical element into another

Which of the following contains the highest number of electrons?
OA) hydroxide ion
OB) oxonium ion
C) ammonium ion
OD) oxide ion
O E) all of them contains the same number of electrons

Answers

I think it’s A if wrong than sorry

how a scientist might use a graph of the
relationship between population growth and time to identify
a trend

Answers

Agora hemorrhage resqoio

7.In the oxidation of ethane: 2 C2H6 + 7 02 + 4CO2 + 6H2O how many
liters of O2 are required to react with 90 grams of ethane?

Answers

Answer:

If reaction is taking place at room temperature and pressure(rtp)

= 360 litres of O₂ at rtp

If reaction is taking place at  standard temperature and pressure(stp):

= 336 litres of O₂ at stp

Explanation:

2C₂H₆ + 70₂ → 4CO₂ + 6H₂O

1 mole of C₂H₆ =  (12 × 2) + (1 × 6) = 24 + 6 = 30g

2 moles of C₂H₆ = 30 × 2 = 60g

From the equation:

1 mole of 0₂ reacts with 2 moles of C₂H₆

1 mole of 0₂ reacts with  60g  of C₂H₆

? moles of 0₂ react with 90g of C₂H₆

[tex]\frac{90}{60}[/tex]= 1.5 moles of O₂

Considering condition of reaction taking place whether room temperature and pressure(rtp) or standard temperature and pressure(stp)

If room temperature and pressure(rtp):

1 mole of 0₂ occupies 24 liters/24000 cm³/ 24 dm³ of O₂

1.5 moles of O₂ occupies (24 × 1.5)  litres of O₂

= 360 litres of O₂ at rtp

If standard temperature and pressure(stp):

1 mole of 0₂ occupies 22.4 liters/22400 cm³/ 22.4 dm³ of O₂

1.5 moles of O₂ occupies (22,4 × 1.5)  litres of O₂

= 336 litres of O₂ at stp

The Swedish chemist Karl Wilhellm was the first to produce chlorine in the lab
2NaCl + 2H2SO4 + MnO2 -----> Na2SO4 + MnSO4 + H2O + Cl2
If Dr. Wilhellm started with 50.0 g of each reactant, which reactant is the limiting reactant?

Answers

Answer:

Explanation:

Remark

Interesting que8stion. You have to figure out how many mols are present in each reactant. Since all periodic tables are different, I'm going to use rounded numbers. If it is too close, I will go further.

NaCl

Na = 23

Cl = 35.5

1 mol = 58.5 grams

given = 50.0 grams

Mols for the reaction = 50/58.5 = 0.855

H2SO4

H2       =    2*1        2

S          =   1 * 32   32

O4       =   4*16     64

1 mol  =               98   grams

mols  present = 50/98 = 0.510

MnO2

Mn     = 1 * 55    = 55

O2   =   2*16      = 32

1 mol =                  87 grams

mols available    = 50/87 = 0.5747

Discussion

Na Cl and H2SO4 both require 2 moles for every mol of Cl2 produces.

H2SO4  has 0.51 mols available for a reaction

NaCl has  0.855 moles available for a reaction

MnO2 has 0.575 moles available for a reaction.

Given those numbers 0.510 mols of H2SO4 will only produce 0.255 mols of chlorine and the rest will be reduced in a similar manner. H2SO4 is the limiting reagent (reactant).

In other words only 0.510 moles of NaCl will be used and 0.855 - 0.510 moles will be left over on the reactants side.

only 0.575 moles of MnO2 will be used and 0.065 moles will be left over.

The oddity in the result shows up because the balance numbers in the equation give a ratio of 2 to 1 for H2SO4 and NaCl The 2 belongs to the reactants and the 1 for the chlorine.

give same examples of ways that people destroy the plant animals relationship?​

Answers

Human activity is by far the biggest cause of habitat loss. The loss of wetlands, plains, lakes, and other natural environments all destroy or degrade habitat, as do other human activities such as introducing invasive species, polluting, trading in wildlife, and engaging in wars.

4NH3 + 502 - 6H20 + 4NO

How many grams of O2 are required to produce 0.3 mol of H20?


4NH3 + 5O2 --> 6H2O + 4NO

How mant grams of NO are produced from 1.55 mol of NH3?


4NH3 + 5O2 --> 6H2O + 4NO

How many grams of NO is produced if 12g of 02 is combined with ammonia? ​

Answers

Explanation:

4NH3 + 502 - 6H20 + 4NO

How many grams of O2 are required to produce 0.3 mol of H20?

4NH3 + 5O2 --> 6H2O + 4NO

How mant grams of NO are produced from 1.55 mol of NH3?

4NH3 + 5O2 --> 6H2O + 4NO

How many grams of NO is produced if 12g of 02 is combined with ammonia?

What is the correct definition of temperature

Answers

Answer:

i'm pretty sure its the last answer and if not its the 2nd one

please help i don’t know this:(

Answers

Answer:

29.5 days

Explanation:

orginally 27.3 days but 29.5 days is also correct

When H2(g) reacts with F2(g) to form HF(g) , 542 kJ of energy are evolved for each mole of H2(g) that reacts. Write a balanced thermochemical equation for the reaction with an energy term in kJ as part of the equation.

Answers

Answer:

H₂(g) + F₂(g) ⇒ 2 HF(g)   ΔH°rxn = -542 kJ

Explanation:

Let's consider the unbalanced equation that occcurs when H₂(g) reacts with F₂(g) to form HF(g).

H₂(g) + F₂(g) ⇒ HF(g)

In order to get the balanced equation, we will multiply HF(g) by 2.

H₂(g) + F₂(g) ⇒ 2 HF(g)

To convert a balanced equation into a thermochemical equation, we need to add the standard enthaply of the reaction, considering that 542 kJ of energy are evolved for each mole of H₂(g) and there is 1 mole of H₂(g) in the balanced equation. By convention, when energy is released, it takes a negative sign. The thermochemical equation is:

H₂(g) + F₂(g) ⇒ 2 HF(g)   ΔH°rxn = -542 kJ

Write a balanced equation for the double-replacement precipitation reaction described, using the smallest possible integer coefficients. A precipitate forms when aqueous solutions of nickel(II) nitrate and sodium carbonate are combined. Do not include states such as (s) or (aq). It is not necessary for you to indicate which of the products is the precipitate.

Answers

Answer:

Ni(NO₃)₂ + Na₂CO₃ ⇒ NiCO₃ + 2 NaNO₃

Explanation:

Let's consider the unbalanced equation for the reaction that occurs when aqueous solutions of nickel(II) nitrate and sodium carbonate are combined. This is a double-replacement precipitation reaction.

Ni(NO₃)₂ + Na₂CO₃ ⇒ NiCO₃ + NaNO₃

We will balance the equation using the trial and error method.

First, we will balance Na atoms by multiplying NaNO₃ by 2.

Ni(NO₃)₂ + Na₂CO₃ ⇒ NiCO₃ + 2 NaNO₃

As we can see, the equation is balanced.

PLEASE HURRY!!!
It took Mrs. Murphy 5.5 hours traveling at a rate of 113 km/hr to finally reach her parents house.
How far did she travel?

Answers

She would have traveled 621.5 kilometers.
The answer is 621.5/hr, you just multiple the rate and the number of hours she traveled

Use the crisscross method to find the chemical formula for the ionic compound formed by aluminum (Al) and sulfur (S). A. Al₂S2 B. AlzS3 C. Al3S2 D. Als​

Answers

Answer:Al2s3

Explanation:

Just took quiz

what element in magma is most abundant

Answers

Oxygen :) hope it helped

Answer:

Oxygen and Silicon

Explanation:

Oxygen and Silicon are the most abundant elements in magma, SiO₂

-TheUnknownScientist

Which of the two Lewis/electron dot structure representations, which is
the correct one for oxygen gas? PICTURE BELOW

Answers

Answer:

A

Explanation:

Generally the ionization potential in a period increases, but there are some exceptions. The one which is not an exception is
1) Be & B 2) N & O 3) Mg & Al 4) Na & Mg

Answers

Answer:

Generally, the first ionisation energy increases along a period. But there are some exceptions one which is not an exception

HC2HO3(aq)+H2O(l)⇄H3O+(aq)+C2HO3−(aq)
pKa=3.18
at 25°C

The equilibrium for the acid ionization of HC2HO3 is represented by the equation above. If 10.0mL of 0.20MHC2HO3 reacts with 5.0mL of 0.10MNaOH, which of the following could be used to calculate the correct pH of the resulting solution?

A) pH=pKa+log(0.100.20)

B) pH=pKa+log(0.0050×0.100.0100×0.20)

C) pH=pKa+log[((0.0050×0.10)0.0150)/((0.0100×0.20)−(0.0050×0.10)0.0150)]

D) pH=pKa+log[((0.0050×0.10)+(0.0100×0.20)0.0150)/((0.0100×0.20)−(0.0050×0.10)0.0150)]

Answers

Answer:

C) pH=pKa+log[((0.0050×0.10)0.0150)/((0.0100×0.20)−(0.0050×0.10)0.0150)]

Explanation:

To find the pH of a buffer (The mixture of the weak acid and its conjugate base) we have to use Henderson-Hasselbalch equation:

pH = pKa + log [Base] / [Acid]

Where pKa is the pka of the buffer and [] is molar concentration of the species of the buffer

The [Base] is equal to the concentration of NaOH added:

0.10M * (0.005L / 0.015L)

And the concentration of the acid [Acid] is the initial concentration of the acid - the concentration of the NaOH added:

0.0100L * (0.20M)/0.0150L - 0.10M * (0.005L / 0.015L)

That means the pH of the buffer is:

C) pH=pKa+log[((0.0050×0.10)0.0150)/((0.0100×0.20)−(0.0050×0.10)0.0150)]

Answer:

C) pH=pKa+log[((0.0050×0.10)0.0150)/((0.0100×0.20)−(0.0050×0.10)0.0150)]

Explanation:

The equilibrium for the acid ionization of HC2HO3 is represented by the equation above. If 10.0mL of 0.20MHC2HO3 reacts with 5.0mL of 0.10MNaOH, which of the following could be used to calculate the correct pH of the resulting solution. pH=pKa+log[((0.0050×0.10)0.0150)/((0.0100×0.20)−(0.0050×0.10)0.0150)]

Which of the following regions has an economy based on processing food and consumer goods?

A. Western Europe
B. Eastern Europe
C. northern Europe
D. southern Europe


No links plz

Answers

Answer:

B. Eastern Europe

Explanation:

The economy of Eastern Europe depends on producing foods. For example, Poland and Belarus are two countries in Eastern Europe, and they both produce chocolates. Producing foods isn't the only detrimental part of the region's economic data. The other half depends on consumer goods. For example, Estonia and Latvia are good countries in packaging food. The answer to the question is B.

Other Questions
backseat or shotgun? 35. A garden bed is 5m in length, 3m in width and 10cm in height.Find the volume of soil in m3 that will be needed to fill up the garden bed. Angle Sum Theorem3387X = [? ]please help! I will mark brainlest!! Joe wants to place plants around each of four sides of a square yard. If hes planned for each of the four sides to show six plants (including corner plants), how many plants will he need? Below are the ingredients of photosynthesis. Organize them to show what is used and what is producedduring this process.carbon dioxidewateroxygenglucosesunlight_____plus_____in the presence of_____result in_____plus_____ Which scenario best demonstrates a compliance issue?O Melanie believes that her most recent paycheck was incorrect.Bob believes that a co-worker has been lying on her time reporting.Jason dislikes his co-workers and finds them difficult to get along with.Jennifer is angry because she doesn't like her work schedule.SUBMIT Which equation represents a line which is parallel to the line y=7/2x-4 A car advertisement states that a certain car can accelerate from rest to27m/s in 4.9 seconds at a temperature of 75F. What is the acceleration ofthe car? Using complete sentences post a detailed response to the following.Many users do not like pop-ups such as alert boxes. Some people even have pop-up blockers in their browsers, which means that no boxes can pop up. As a website developer, would you include pop-up boxes? Why or why not? Should users block them in their browsers? Molly keeps a record of her money on a calendar. She had $112.64 saved prior to the week shown in the partial calendar. How much money did Molly have left at the end of this week? Hubert lives in San Diego and runs a business that sells boats. In an average year, he receives $851,000 from selling boats. Of this sales revenue, he must pay the manufacturer a wholesale cost of $476,000; he also pays wages and utility bills totaling $281,000. He owns his showroom; if he chooses to rent it out, he will receive $71,000 in rent per year. Assume that the value of this showroom does not depreciate over the year. Also, if Hubert does not operate this boat business, he can work as an accountant, receive an annual salary of $34,000 with no additional monetary costs, and rent out his showroom at the $71,000 per year rate. No other costs are incurred in running this boat business.Identify each of Bob's costs in the following table as either an implicit cost or an explicit cost of selling boats.a. The salary Bob could earn if he worked as an accountant b. The wholesale cost for the boats that Bob pays the manufacturer c. The rental income Bob could receive if he chose to rent out his showroom d. The wages and utility bills that Bob pays Wat two common uses for Zinc??? A six sided die is rolled and a spinner with 5 equal spaces labeled A-E is spun. Find the P(rollinga 1 and spinning A). Answer as simplified fraction. Did the Progressive Reform Movement change the human condition during this era? PLEASE HELP ME. Choose the general rule below that describes the rotation mapping RST to R'S'T'. What should I write an OP about (English 2) 2(3v + 4) + 5(2v 3) = please help methe formulaA=1/2 X bX h Do you agree with Friedman that monopolies are dangerous and that they exploit customers? Or do you feel they serve a positive purpose in the economy? what is the slope of the line?